I Tested And Reviewed 10 Best Deck Boxes For Double Sleeved Commander (2023)

I am absolutely in love with the feel and look of this box. The design is sleek and visually appealing, making it a great addition to any collection. I was pleasantly surprised to find that it also comes with a discount card for future purchases, which made me even more excited about the product. In fact, I loved it so much that I ended up buying two more after my initial purchase.

The size of the box is perfect for holding cards, and I appreciate the middle compartment that allows me to store dice counters. However, I do wish that the dice could fit more snugly in that compartment. While I can fit four dice perfectly on the short side, there is a strange gap when I try to fit as many dice as possible on the long side. It would be great if this issue could be addressed in future versions of the box.

Aside from that minor issue, I am really pleased with this product. It is incredibly sturdy and strikes the perfect balance between providing enough space for a complete card game, such as Arkham Horror or Magic: The Gathering, without being too large and cumbersome to carry in a backpack or luggage. It's the ideal storage solution for my needs.

I purchased two units of this storage box to house my four decks, and I'm very happy with its performance. The construction is top-notch, and it feels incredibly well-made. The compartments snugly fit two double-sleeved commander decks, while the middle tray is perfect for storing tokens and dice. It keeps everything organized and secure.

The deck box has a solid construction and spacious interior, capable of holding a double sleeved 100 card deck for TCG storage. The advertised imprinted design adds a touch of humor and uniqueness, making it a conversation starter among nerd friends. The strong magnetic clasp ensures the lid stays securely closed, minimizing the risk of cards falling out.

One standout feature of this deck box is the absence of any company branding, which sets it apart from similar products. It maintains a clean and minimalist appearance, without any flashy logos or repetitive branding, delivering exactly what was promised.

The box's quality is commendable, with thick wall construction, fabric lining, and a sturdy magnetic closure on the flap. Its square shape adds a touch of distinction, and the stamped attitude on the top offers a fun and playful element. The box remained closed during short drop tests, protecting the cards inside without any damage.

Although it didn't fit into a long storage box due to its slightly taller dimensions, this minor inconvenience doesn't overshadow the box's overall functionality and design.

Compared to other deck boxes, this one stands out as a favorite for its convenience. It provides ample space for a commander deck, along with additional cards, and allows for easy removal and insertion of the deck. Unlike other boxes that can make managing cards a bit tricky, this box's horizontal card placement simplifies the process.

Apart from its practicality, the box also impresses with its aesthetics. It has a sleek and appealing appearance both inside and out, exuding a sense of quality. The strong magnetic lock ensures that even when turned upside down and shaken, the cards remain securely in place.

Considering all these features, it is difficult to find any flaws or drawbacks with this deck box. It is a highly recommended option for TCG enthusiasts looking for a reliable and stylish solution for their card storage needs.

I am extremely pleased with this deck box. It is the perfect size for storing my commander deck and tokens. Even though I double-sleeve my cards, I am still able to fit them all in, albeit with a bit of a tight fit. I have also found that printed proxy decks on cardstock can fit comfortably in this box, especially if the excess air is squeezed out of the sleeves. Overall, I am very satisfied with this box and will definitely be purchasing more in the future. The price is great and I have not encountered any issues thus far.

One minor drawback is the limited color options and lack of designs available. However, this is not a dealbreaker for me as the functionality of the box outweighs the need for aesthetics. The capacity of the box is impressive, even with only single-sleeved cards. There is still plenty of extra room for additional cards. The magnetic seal keeps the box securely closed and I have not experienced any issues with it. The box itself has a simple design but feels nice to the touch.

I recently purchased numerous MTG commander decks and needed storage boxes to keep them organized. I was not satisfied with the cheap paper boxes that came with the decks, as they lacked durability. Instead, I opted to use these boxes and have already acquired around 20 of them. They have proven to be perfect for my needs and work exceptionally well. However, it is worth noting that I do not sleeve my cards, so I cannot comment on how well the box holds sleeved cards.

In terms of storage capacity, this deck box comfortably holds my 100-card magic deck using Sealable Dragon Shield inner sleeves and Dragon Shield outer sleeves. It even has room for 15 tokens, with the potential for more if one takes the time to straighten the cards when placing them in the box. The inner cardboard is fairly sturdy and can withstand accidental drops from the table, although I would not recommend subjecting it to excessive force as it may damage the cards. The outer material of the deck box is hydrophobic, providing protection against spills. However, I would not leave it in contact with water for an extended period as it may seep into the stitching.

The overall quality of this deck box is superb. The magnets used for the seal are strong and reliable. The material used appears to be of high quality and the cards fit securely within the box. Additionally, I appreciate the inclusion of two separators that come with the box, allowing for easy organization. I have not encountered a single issue or problem with this product and highly recommend it.

I recently purchased this deck box and I must say, it is a game-changer! As someone with a thick deck that requires double-sleeving for optimal protection, I have struggled to find a box that can accommodate its size. Many boxes on the market claim to be spacious enough, but they always fall short when put to the test. However, this box exceeded my expectations.

The moment I slipped my deck into this box, I knew I had found the perfect solution. It fits my deck snugly, providing the right amount of space without being too loose. This ensures that my cards stay secure and well-protected at all times. Finally, I can confidently carry my deck without worrying about any damage.

This deck box is specifically designed for Magic The Gathering Commander format, and it effortlessly holds up to 100 single-sleeved cards. I personally use dragonshield sleeves, and they fit comfortably in this box. However, I cannot vouch for its compatibility with double-sleeved decks. The box also comes with a convenient divider, although it is not shown in the picture. This divider allows for easy organization and even has room for a few tokens.

I am so impressed with this product that I had to purchase another one. In the future, I plan to buy another for my Yugioh and Magic cards as well. The durability and functionality of this deck box make it a worthwhile investment for any card game enthusiast.

It's worth mentioning that this box is also suitable for holding two sleeved Oathbreaker decks. However, I do hope that more designs are introduced in this size range. Having two identical boxes can be a bit monotonous, and some variety in design would be greatly appreciated.

While this deck box has numerous merits, I must caution Pokémon card players. Unfortunately, the box is too wide for Pokémon cards, causing them to move around inside the box. If you primarily play Pokémon, I would recommend exploring other options to ensure a secure fit for your cards.

I purchased this deck box as a gift for my partner, and they absolutely love it. They primarily use it for their Magic the Gathering commander deck cards, and it fits them snugly. The box also has room in the middle for a few dice sets, which is a nice added feature. The overall quality of the box is impressive, as it is made of high-quality pleather and feels well put together. It definitely feels like it will last for a long time.

One minor drawback I noticed is that the box can be a bit difficult to remove when it's full of cards. It's hard to find a good grip to pull the cards out easily. However, I plan on modifying it by adding a ribbon, so my partner can simply tug on the ribbon to remove the insert. Other than that, I have no complaints about this product. It's exactly what I was looking for and my partner is very happy with it.

The box is sturdy and can hold 100 double-sleeved MTG-sized cards in each compartment. The tray in the middle is spacious enough to accommodate several bundle oversized dice or other items of similar size. The color of the box I received was pink and black, which differs from the red and black shown in the product picture. Nevertheless, the box still appears to be durable and provides excellent protection for my cards. It is also very portable, which is a plus.

In terms of functionality, the box easily accommodates my commander decks and a decent amount of tokens in each compartment, even when single-sleeved. The middle compartment comfortably fits around 12-13 dice. The magnets used to secure the box are of good quality and passed a light shake test without any issues. While the materials used may not feel as high quality as those from Gamegenic, the price difference of $20 makes it a worthwhile purchase. I did have to deduct a star due to the box arriving slightly damaged, but overall, I can still recommend this product.

As a first-time deck box user, I find it convenient for storing my dice and counters in the middle compartment. However, it doesn't perfectly fit them in a row, which can be a bit annoying. Nonetheless, the box serves its purpose well by keeping everything safely inside. It may require some effort to take the cards out at times, but it still functions perfectly fine. Overall, it's a good buy and I'm satisfied with my purchase.

The deck box with card sleeves is a great option for those looking to store their card collections. It is spacious enough to accommodate a double-sleeved 100 card commander deck along with additional cards and tokens. The build quality of the box is good, with strong magnets ensuring that the cards stay securely in place even when the box is shaken. Considering the price of the box, which also includes extra sleeves, it is hard to find a better deal elsewhere. However, it is worth mentioning that at the time of purchase, there were no other color options available.

In terms of assembly, the box is well put together with sturdy stitching. In case the glue starts to wear off, it can easily be fixed. The design of the box is also commendable, as there is no shelf inside that could potentially damage the cards. With enough room for a 100 card double-sleeved deck, there is also ample space for additional cards. Compared to other boxes from top brands, this box may not have all the extra features such as an elastic band or fully removable cover, but it makes up for it by providing a storage compartment that doesn't pose a risk of card damage and offers more room. It has become a personal favorite among the various boxes purchased recently.

For those looking to store Blades in the Dark RPG cards, this box is the perfect size, accommodating a total of 246 unsleeved cards with extra room to spare. However, it would be beneficial if more dividers were included with the box.

I recently purchased this card deck box and I must say, it is truly impressive. In terms of quality, it stands right alongside my Ultimate Guard Sidewinder, which is known for its durability. The box is spacious enough to comfortably fit my single sleeved commander deck, with even some extra room for additional tokens if needed. What really impressed me is the strength of the magnetic closure. Even when I turned the box upside down and shook it vigorously, the cards remained securely in place.

Not only is this deck box of high quality, but it is also reasonably priced. I have spent over $25 on other well-known deck box brands, but this one definitely holds its own. I highly recommend giving it a try. In fact, I am considering purchasing a few more in different colors for my other commander decks.

One of the standout features of this deck box is its side loading design, which is not commonly found in other options. This makes it incredibly convenient to access the cards inside. Additionally, it can comfortably hold a single sleeved commander deck of 100 cards, along with 20 tokens. If you wanted to maximize the space, you could even fit an additional 20 cards before it starts feeling cramped. Finding a deck box with enough dice storage for token decks is also quite rare, but this one delivers on that front.

Furthermore, this deck box serves as my go-to option for traveling or playing outside of my home or the card shop. It is compact and self-contained, with the added bonus of a functional playmat on the external cover. This playmat is much more practical compared to other deck boxes that simply offer an afterthought playmat option.

The customer service provided by the seller was exceptional, and the shipping was incredibly fast. I was excited to sleeve up my decks and put this deck box to use as soon as it arrived.

The overall quality of this deck box blew me away. The closure is tight and secure, thanks to the strong magnets that snap it closed. The interior is soft and can easily accommodate 100 cards and tokens in the 100+ version. On the outside, the box feels sturdy and has a vibrant color that adds to its appeal. I cannot stress enough how fantastic this deck box is and I highly recommend it to anyone in need of a reliable and stylish storage solution.

The side loading feature of this deck box is truly fantastic, as it makes accessing the cards much easier. The top lid is securely attached, which may be a positive or negative depending on personal preference. Personally, I prefer the lid to fully come off, but this design works perfectly fine. The vibrant red interior adds a pop of color and provides enough space for a single sleeved 100 card commander deck. I cannot say for sure if it can accommodate double sleeved decks, but it appears to have the potential to do so. In the photos I have, I was able to fit 100+ rares in perfect fit sleeves, with the possibility of fitting an additional 20-30 cards. The materials used feel durable and the box itself exudes a sense of sturdiness. Considering the price, it is definitely a worthwhile investment. The vibrant red interior is a standout feature that adds to the overall appeal of this deck box.

The box is the perfect size for transporting Magic The Gathering accessories. It comfortably fits a 100-card Commander deck in sleeves in the large compartment, with plenty of room to spare. I use the smaller compartment for token cards and the drawer for DnD dice and small dice for game pieces. The exterior of the box has a pleasant, rough texture, and the design is very stylish. The magnetic closure mechanism works well, and I hope it lasts for a long time. I will provide an update if anything changes in the future. Overall, it is a superb product.

I was pleasantly surprised by the sturdiness of the box, considering Amazon's habit of shipping items without proper packaging. My box arrived with just a slight dent at the hinge, which speaks to its durability. It should hold up well during backpack travel for many years. The box has a large capacity and can hold a lot of cards. In the photos, I have one of my EDH decks with 20 alternate cards in the main compartment, with room to spare. In the left compartment, I have two 40-card draft decks with additional space. I had 200 sleeved cards in total and could have fit in another 20. The dice tray is secure but easy to open and close. Overall, it is a great box for its listed price of $24.99, which is comparable to other similar box designs on the market.

Mi serviva un porta mazzo per trasportare il mio commander, più una trentina di carte extra per convertire il suddetto da incolore a verde. Il porta mazzo è molto robusto e possiede un utile comparto ove inserire i dadi e, all'occorrenza, rimovibile per aggiungere altre carte. Il vano più grande può contenere più di 100 carte da sole, ma è sufficientemente grande per contenere un commander inserito nelle doppie sleeve.

The Commander deck box is a fantastic storage solution for both Commander and standard decks. It has the capacity to hold up to 80 sleeved cards, making it perfect for gamers who like to have multiple decks on hand. The third compartment is a great addition, providing ample space for d20s and tokens.

One of the standout features of this deck box is the strong magnets that keep everything securely inside and protected. This is a major advantage, as it ensures that your cards and accessories won't accidentally fall out during transport.

The quality of the box is top-notch, with a premium outer material that not only feels great but also provides a good grip. The magnets are also very strong, further enhancing the overall durability of the box. It's clear that a lot of thought has been put into the design and construction of this product.

In terms of storage capacity, the large compartment can comfortably accommodate over 100 double sleeved cards, while the smaller compartment can hold around 50. There's even extra room at the top to allow for dividers, which is a nice touch. This is particularly noteworthy because most premium deck boxes only provide a snug fit for standard-size sleeves, whereas this box has ample space for sleeve protectors or outer sleeves.

The size and quality of this deck box make it a great choice for anyone looking to store their deck, dice, and token cards in one convenient place. It's sturdy, secure, and offers plenty of room for all your gaming essentials.

The only minor downside is the limited color choices available. While the overall functionality and quality of the box are excellent, some users may prefer a greater variety of colors to choose from.

I have been playing EDH for a while now and have tried out various deck boxes throughout the years. However, I always faced the same issue – most boxes do not comfortably fit double sleeved 100 card decks. That's why I decided to give this deck box a try, and I must say, it has become my go-to choice.

One of the things that stood out to me is the affordability. For just over 30 dollars, I can get two of these boxes, making it a much more cost-effective option compared to other similar quality boxes on the market. Not only that, but these boxes have proven to be capable of accommodating my double sleeved Dragon Shield decks perfectly. They fit snugly, without being too tight.

Another great feature of this deck box is the added tray for tokens and dice. This makes it even more convenient and practical to use. I love how I can fit everything I need in one box without having to carry around additional items. It truly enhances the overall utility of the product.

In fact, I am so satisfied with this deck box that I currently own two of them and I am considering getting another one. They are spacious enough to fit two double sleeved MTG Commander decks if needed. I use one box for each of my decks, and the other slot is perfect for storing tokens, a life counter, and mini dice. It's a sturdy and efficient solution.

Additionally, I have found that this deck box is not limited to just Magic: The Gathering. As a Yugioh player, I can comfortably fit 75 cards, each double sleeved in Dragon Shield Perfect Fit sealable and dual Matt card sleeves, in each deck slot. It's a good purchase that caters to different card game enthusiasts.