I Tested And Reviewed 10 Best Electric Fireplace Insert For Existing Fireplace (2023)

I recently purchased this fireplace and I must say, it has exceeded my expectations. As someone who loves the cozy ambiance of a fire, but hates the lingering smell of smoke, I've been on the hunt for the perfect solution. Despite its slightly higher price tag, I decided to give this fireplace a chance because it appeared to have the most realistic bed of coals and logs compared to others on the market.

First and foremost, the appearance of this fireplace is absolutely stunning. Even when turned off, it adds a touch of elegance to any room. When it's on, the bed of glowing embers with flickering flames above, topped with the logs, creates a remarkably realistic fire effect. What impressed me even more was how the rolling fire effect not only goes through the logs but also reflects off the back of the fireplace, enhancing the overall authenticity. It truly gives off that cozy feel I was hoping for.

In terms of functionality, the heater is surprisingly powerful. Even on the highest setting, it quickly and effectively blows hot air, providing ample warmth. I have no complaints in this aspect and am thoroughly satisfied with its performance.

However, I do have mixed feelings about the sound. On the low setting, the crackling sound is pleasant and subtle, enhancing the overall experience. However, on the high setting, it becomes slightly tinny and less enjoyable due to a small and weak speaker. While this is a minor setback, I am considering replacing the speaker with a better one in the future. Nevertheless, the sound issue does not greatly impact my overall satisfaction with the fireplace.

One feature that I found to be a bit unnecessary is the wind sound. While I understand the intention behind it (to simulate a fire on a windy day), it ends up sounding like someone frying bacon in a pan. Personally, I see no practical reason to use this feature. However, I believe this is a minor flaw that does not significantly affect the fireplace's overall performance, so I will not deduct any stars for it.

The remote control is simple and user-friendly, making it easy to operate the fireplace. One thing to note is that the remote sensor is tucked away under the "grate," so it's important to aim the remote in the right spot for it to work properly. This is a minor inconvenience but not a deal-breaker.

As I sit next to the fireplace while writing this review, I cannot help but appreciate the cozy atmosphere it creates. Occasionally, I catch a glimpse of the warm glow and momentarily forget that it's made of metal and plastic, expecting to feel the heat radiating from the fire. However, this is a minor observation and does not diminish my overall satisfaction with the fireplace.

I recently purchased a gas fireplace insert to replace my old gas fireplace, and I couldn't be happier with my decision. Installing the insert was a breeze, as I simply had to cap off the gas pipe and fit the insert into place. The only issue I encountered was that the length of the insert was slightly shorter than what I needed due to my own measuring mistake. However, this was a minor inconvenience that did not affect the overall functionality of the insert.

One thing I noticed is that there is a noticeable sound when the heater is turned on. However, this was easily remedied by adjusting the volume of my TV, which effectively covered up the noise. Despite this minor drawback, I would still highly recommend this gas fireplace insert as it has been a great purchase for me.

The flame effects of the insert are truly impressive and look incredibly realistic. Unlike my previous electric fireplace, which offered only five flame color options that never looked authentic, this gas fireplace insert provides a single flame color that is a perfect mix of colors, creating a visually appealing and authentic-looking flame. My only wish is that the insert was slightly larger, but I am able to mitigate this by flashing it to the fireplace opening, which fills the gap nicely.

The insert arrived promptly as advertised, and I was pleased to find that there was no assembly required. My husband, who is a carpenter, was able to build the necessary modifications to ensure that the unit fit perfectly into our antique mantle. The remote control allows for easy regulation of both the heat output and the height of the artificial flame, which adds to the overall convenience of this insert. I am thoroughly satisfied with how the insert looks, but unfortunately, the unit ran continuously and did not shut off automatically as it was supposed to. As a result, I had to return it for a replacement.

When I moved into my 60s ranch house, I wanted to add a fireplace to enhance the ambiance of my living room. Instead of framing one into the wall, I decided to convert a credenza, and it turned out to be a fantastic choice. Prepping the credenza was a straightforward process, and all I had to do was slide in the insert and plug it in. The view of the artificial flames and the comforting heat it produces are truly enjoyable.

I made sure to leave enough space behind and above the insert for proper air circulation, and I am pleased to report that the heat radiates effectively out of the front, just as it should. This gas fireplace insert has been a great purchase for me, and I couldn't be happier with the way it has transformed my living room.

The fireplace insert that I purchased exceeded my expectations in terms of its realistic appearance and overall stunning design. It seamlessly fits into the hole I cut to the specified measurements, adding a touch of sophistication to my living space. However, I would like to mention a minor detail that previous reviews failed to address. The plug for the fireplace is located on the side, rather than the back. This means that when creating the cutout, it is important to consider the position of the plug. Either the hole should be shallow enough for the plug to rest behind it or a space should be carved out to accommodate the plug. This detail may seem insignificant, but it is worth noting to ensure a seamless installation.

Upon receiving the fireplace on February 1st, 2022, I promptly installed it in my existing wood-burning fireplace as I no longer burn wood. The end result is truly remarkable, resembling the work of a professional installation. One of the standout features of this fireplace is its ability to change colors, creating a dynamic ambiance in the room.

I made the decision to purchase this fireplace after conducting extensive research, and I am pleased to report that it was delivered on time, well-packaged, and complete. However, during the installation process, I encountered an issue with the control board. I contacted the seller, who promptly responded and provided a new board. The replacement was easy to install, and I appreciate the seller's swift resolution of the problem. In a gesture of gratitude for my patience, the seller also refunded a portion of the purchase price. It is refreshing to encounter a seller who genuinely cares about their customers' satisfaction. As of now, the fireplace unit is functioning well, and I will provide further updates if necessary.

The fireplace insert fits perfectly, aligning flawlessly with our existing setup. We particularly appreciate the convenience of the remote control, which allows us to adjust the flame size and colors according to our preferences. Additionally, the fireplace provides optional heat, adding to its functionality. However, we found the crackling sound option to be less realistic, so we will likely not utilize that feature. Overall, we are extremely satisfied with the product.

Upon receiving the fireplace, I noticed a slight bend on one side. However, I am confident that it can be easily bent back into shape. The remote control initially required multiple button presses before responding, so I reached out to the seller. I am confident that they will promptly send a replacement remote. Besides these minor issues, the fireplace is perfect and fits flawlessly. The heat it emits is also pleasant. As a resident of an RV, I struggled to find a fireplace mantle that would fit in the corner, as most were too large. To solve this problem, I repurposed a white bookcase that I purchased from Target ten years ago for $60. After disassembling, sanding, priming, and painting the individual pieces, I reassembled them to create a customized fireplace mantel. To add a unique touch, I used contact paper to create an appealing design. The top part of the bookcase, which is adjustable, allowed me to drill holes according to the measurements of the fireplace. I am now eagerly awaiting the completion of my new floors and the opportunity to paint my walls. On the first day of using the fireplace, I am already extremely satisfied with its performance. Apart from the remote control issue, everything works perfectly, and the heat output is excellent. I will provide updates if any issues arise in the future.

Update: I contacted the seller regarding the dent on the fireplace, and they offered a 15% refund as an alternative to returning the product. We decided to keep the fireplace and bend out the dent ourselves. The seller promptly provided a tracking number for a replacement remote. Their willingness to work with us and their offer of a partial refund demonstrated their excellent customer service. We accepted the offer and are happy with the resolution.

I recently purchased this fireplace for my elderly mother, and she couldn't be happier with it. It arrived quickly and even earlier than expected, which was a pleasant surprise. Although we live in Arizona and haven't had the chance to use the heat function yet, my mother believes it will keep the living room warm and hopes she won't have to rely on the central heater this year. The only downside is that it didn't fit into her existing trapezoid-shaped fireplace, but we can't deduct any stars for that as it was due to the fireplace's unique shape.

My mother uses the fireplace every morning and night and absolutely loves the cozy ambiance it creates. The remote control is very convenient for her, and she finds it easy to use, thanks to its simple design. The flame design, although not realistic, adds a warm and inviting glow to the room, and my mother appreciates the effort put into replicating fire.

In comparison to our old fireplace insert, this one is much quieter, and we appreciate the thermostat control feature. It provides a decent amount of heat, although we do miss the option of a higher fan setting without adjusting the temperature. The flame effect, while not convincing as a real fire, still creates a pleasant glow in the room. Overall, we believe this fireplace is a great value and would recommend it to others. It was also incredibly easy to install, replacing our old unit seamlessly.

We recently installed this fireplace in our motorhome, and it's been a perfect fit for our small space. We love the thermostat, remote control, and display, all of which enhance the convenience and functionality of the fireplace. The seller provided excellent service, and our order arrived within a week, which was impressive. Additionally, the one-year warranty gives us peace of mind, especially considering other fireplaces we considered only had a 90-day warranty.

UPDATE: Unfortunately, after less than six months of use, the lights that create the flame effect burned out. While we expected the company to send replacement bulbs, they surprised us by sending a complete new unit. Although we had to reinstall it, we quickly tested it during the summer months, and the heater seemed to be working fine. However, when we turned it on today as the temperatures dipped, we discovered that the flames have completely stopped working. This is an extremely frustrating experience, and we are now uncertain about recommending this product.

I recently had a custom fireplace built in my master bedroom and after extensive research, I decided to go with a faux fireplace/heater. The one I chose has proven to be the perfect size and offers multiple color settings. Not only does it function as a real heater, but it also comes with a convenient remote control. With timer settings of up to 8 hours and the option to run without heat or set the desired temperature, this fireplace provides flexibility and convenience. I was particularly impressed with the cooling fan, which quickly lowers the temperature after the heat is turned off, ensuring that the surrounding areas remain cool to the touch.

What sets this fireplace apart is the option to choose between a wood look and glass crystals. Both options create a glowing and reflective effect, with the crystals lending a more modern look. As someone with a real gas fireplace, I appreciate the contemporary aesthetic of this fireplace, as well as the calming color combinations and realistic-looking flames.

In terms of packaging and installation, I found the product to be well-packaged and easy to install. It simply plugs into a standard outlet, and it comes with both fake logs and clear stones to suit personal preferences. Personally, I prefer the log option, but it's nice to have the choice. I was pleasantly surprised by how quickly the fireplace heated up my sunroom, and it also cooled down in a reasonable amount of time. Considering my previous experience with a louder tower heater, I expected this fireplace to be noisier, but it turned out to be relatively quiet. Overall, I highly recommend this fireplace for anyone looking to heat a room or create a cozy ambiance.

While the fireplace itself is great, I did encounter a minor issue with the remote control. It stopped working a week after purchase. However, I reached out to the company and they promptly sent me a replacement remote. This level of customer service impressed me, and it solidified my confidence in the quality of this fireplace.

The Duraflame Electric Fireplace Log Set is a great option for those looking to add a realistic flame effect to their unused fireplace. Unlike other electric fireplace inserts, this log set does not require specific measurements or a reflective glass front. It simply sits in the fireplace, making it easy to install.

One of the standout features of this log set is the adjustable flame effect. The flames are projected onto a reflective surface, which can be adjusted to create the desired level of realism. Moving the unit closer or farther away from the reflective surface allows for further customization. Compared to other electric fireplaces on the market, the flame effect on this log set is fairly realistic.

The logs themselves are well-crafted and visually appealing, even when the unit is turned off. The log set operates quietly, with only a small fan noise when the heater is turned on. This noise is comparable to other electric heaters or the blower on a real fireplace, so it is not bothersome.

While the log set does not produce crackling fire sounds, the Comfort Smart crackle box can be purchased separately to add this feature. The heater generates a significant amount of heat and is capable of warming up a room effectively. However, it is important to note that the log set can get quite hot, so it should not be used without a heat barrier.

One user did experience some damage to the log set when it arrived, despite ordering a listing that claimed the damage was only to the box. However, the user was able to use andirons to conceal the damage, and the log set worked perfectly fine. It is worth noting that this user purchased the log set from the Amazon outlet store, so it is possible that the damage was an isolated incident.

The electric log set is a fantastic alternative for those who are unable to use gas logs or prefer not to. The LED simulated ember glow and flames are incredibly realistic and can be used with or without the electric heat. While the heat output may not match that of a gas log set, it still provides a decent amount of warmth, similar to a portable electric space heater.

One of the great advantages of this electric log set is its versatility. It can be installed in a fireplace or virtually anywhere else, making it a convenient option for various setups. Initially, I had doubts when ordering, but I am thoroughly pleased with the product. Everyone who has seen it is also impressed. We purchased it for my mother, who has a log fireplace with no access to gas. She had been regretting not being able to install gas logs, so we decided to give this electric log set a try, and it did not disappoint.

There are a few minor drawbacks to note. Some users have reported an annoying buzz or hum when the heater is turned on. However, the lights on the log set do an excellent job of mimicking a real fire. The flame effect towards the back of the log set may not be as bright as desired, and the overall brightness of the fireplace could be improved. However, upon contacting the company, they promptly sent a replacement log set, resolving these issues. The new log set had no buzz or hum, and the flame was brighter. The heater also provided a nice, warm ambiance.

I ordered the 24" log set after viewing the actual product in a store, where it was priced $50.00 higher. Although the store couldn't find the remote and it was the last one, I decided to proceed with the purchase. I had an electrician come in to thread the wire to a basement outlet since our room didn't have a nearby electrical outlet, and our fireplace was no longer up to code due to a wooden mantel. To enhance the authenticity, I added some real logs to the back and a few pine cones, as the heat blows out towards the front. The log set works perfectly in one of our three fireplaces, alongside the existing wood-burning insert, without interfering with the functioning or safety of the others. The warmth and ambiance it provides have made the room much cozier, and we find ourselves using it more often.

I was initially hesitant to order this item because it wasn't sold as a "Prime" item, but I decided to take the plunge and I'm so glad I did. The delivery was incredibly fast, despite a small delay with FedEx, and the packaging was top-notch. The fireplace and trim kit came with clear instructions and all the necessary parts, making setup a breeze. I opted for a smaller insert and the trim kit, which not only gave the fireplace a sleeker look but also created a better seal against the wall. The trim kit even had a notch for routing the power cord, which I easily concealed with a white extension cord. The fireplace has a range of features, including adjustable flame height and speed, different accent color shades, and even cracking sounds. While some of the sounds may not be completely realistic, they still add to the ambiance. The heat output is decent, covering approximately 400 square feet. Overall, I'm extremely impressed with this purchase and consider it one of the best things I've ever bought on Amazon.

Now, let's talk about the journey I went through to find the right fireplace. I needed a replacement for the original fireplace in my 5th wheel, and finding the right size proved to be a challenge. The dimensions provided by sellers and manufacturers were often incorrect or misleading. After exhausting all possible options, I ended up returning a unit that didn't fit properly. However, this fireplace came through as advertised, with accurate dimensions and a perfect fit for my needs. It was easy to install, looks classy, operates quietly, and exceeds my expectations. It's even better than the fireplace it replaced. So, if you double-check your measurements and take the time to research, you can confidently purchase this fireplace and be just as satisfied as I am.

I recently purchased this electric fireplace and so far, I am quite satisfied with it. After reading numerous reviews, I decided to choose this model due to its dimensions and BTU rating. Our wood-burning fireplace from 1966 has proven to be inefficient and not warm enough for our 600 sq ft room with radiant floor heat. I wanted something that could utilize the existing fireplace while providing enough warmth for a few hours in the evening.

The crackle sound feature, although not very realistic, can be turned off if desired. The fan blower operates quietly, which is a plus. I was pleased to see that the internal thermostat was able to raise the room temperature from 57 to 65 degrees Fahrenheit within an hour on the high blower setting. Even after turning off the fireplace, the room remained warm. The power button door is sturdy and easy to open, and the included remote is a nice touch, although it's not necessary since the fireplace can be controlled directly.

In terms of appearance, the fireplace seems well-built and visually appealing. It fits perfectly in my 36×27 opening, and I particularly like the black power cord. I personally prefer the fireplace without the ambient light feature, as it looks more realistic to me. My only minor gripes are that I wish the fireplace was a bit deeper to allow the logs to sit further away from the glass, and that the faux brick on the inside covered the back where the flame screen is located.

When it comes to the realistic appearance, this fireplace exceeds expectations for its price range. I was specifically looking for a fireplace that closely resembled a real fire and had heating capabilities, and this model has met my requirements. When building our new house, we were presented with the option of a gas fireplace for over $2000 or an electric fireplace for $900. After reading reviews on Amazon, I decided to purchase this particular model for around $310.

Setting up the fireplace was a breeze. I placed it in the designated hole in the fireplace opening, plugged it in, and turned it on within a matter of minutes. The packaging was well-done, ensuring that the fireplace was protected during shipping. It offers a variety of color settings and light intensity options, but I found that the standard setting looks the most realistic. Additionally, it includes a 1500 watt heater that blows air out of the top, providing some heat, although it may not be sufficient for larger rooms.

While this fireplace does not exactly replicate a real flame, it comes close enough for those seeking a realistic appearance. The ability to use the fireplace without the heat function makes it suitable for year-round use. I must emphasize that this fireplace is not intended to heat a large room, but rather a smaller space. If you are looking for a cost-effective option that closely resembles a real flame, this electric fireplace is a great choice.

The electric fireplace is a perfect solution for those who want to enjoy the warmth and ambiance of a fireplace without the hassle of burning wood. This particular fireplace is a great fit for the space, especially for those who have an old wood-burning fireplace that they no longer wish to use.

One of the standout features of this fireplace is its easy installation process. It fits perfectly in the designated space and even comes with a power cord that can be connected to an appliance extension cord for flexibility in reaching the nearest outlet. The fact that it arrived earlier than expected is also a bonus.

In terms of functionality, this fireplace performs admirably. It effectively heats up a room of about 600 sq ft in just 20 minutes, making it much more comfortable to spend time in that particular space. The touch buttons on the fireplace work very well, allowing for easy operation.

There are a few minor drawbacks to consider. The remote control does not function well, even with a direct line of sight, and only works about 30% of the time. Additionally, depending on the speed at which the flames are set, there may be a slight "humming" noise. However, this noise is only bothersome in a completely silent room.

Despite these small issues, the overall experience with this electric fireplace is positive. In fact, the reviewer plans on purchasing another one to add to their double-sided fireplace. They will update on whether the remote and humming issues persist or if it was specific to this particular unit.

The reviewer mentions that they researched extensively to find an electric fireplace of this size with a heater. They were specifically looking for one that could fit into their existing 34" opening in a cabinet, had blue as one of the flame colors, and was shipped by Amazon. This fireplace checked all the boxes and was delivered in just two days, which exceeded their expectations.

While the flames could reach higher up the glass and the heat output could be stronger, the reviewer is still satisfied with the performance of this fireplace. They appreciate the simplicity of plugging it in and how it seamlessly fits into their cabinet. The varied flame colors, including blue, add a nice touch to the overall aesthetic.

Another reviewer highlights the benefits of using this electric fireplace as a replacement for a wood-burning fireplace. It allows them to continue using their fireplace without the need for expensive renovations to meet safety standards. The remote control is easy to use, and the different color lighting options create a pleasant mood effect.

The heat output of this fireplace is exceptional, even in a room with high cathedral ceilings. The installation process is simple, and the fireplace fits perfectly into the existing opening with minimal gaps. The reviewer plans to purchase trim to cover the small gap for aesthetic purposes.

The only complaint mentioned by this reviewer is the late arrival of the fireplace, well past the expected delivery date. However, they acknowledge that the delay may have been due to inclement weather affecting the factory. Despite this issue, the company's lack of communication, and their slow responsiveness, the reviewer praises Amazon for taking care of them by issuing a credit as an apology.