I Tested And Reviewed 10 Best Flushing Toilet At Home Depot (2023)

After trying various toilet cleaning solutions over the years, I have discovered that the most effective ones are those that pass through the flush system and reach the holes around the rim. While clip-on bowl cleaners may look cute, they are not very effective in keeping the toilet clean.

Many tank-based cleaning solutions in the market are effective but can be harmful to the internal components of the toilet, leading to premature failure and potential property damage. However, the Fluidmaster cleaning system offers an innovative and safe solution. It consists of a small unit that connects to the refill line, between the fill valve and refill tube. This unit accepts a replaceable bleach cartridge and is completely sealed. When the toilet is flushed, water passes through the cleaning system and directly into the refill tube. This ensures that the cleaning solution is evenly distributed without entering the tank, using clean water from the tank to flush followed by the cleaning solution as the toilet refills.

The bleach cartridges in the Fluidmaster system last approximately 3 months, depending on the usage. Unlike bleach tablets that dissolve continuously even without use, the Fluidmaster cartridges are only used when the toilet is flushed. This makes them a more efficient and cost-effective option.

I have found the Fluidmaster cleaning system to be the best solution for keeping toilets clean. It is simple, affordable, and highly effective. In fact, I was so impressed with the results that I ended up purchasing three more units for my other toilets. If you dislike the constant need for scrubbing toilets, this system is definitely worth considering.

Furthermore, Fluidmaster offers a convenient reminder service on their website, so you never forget to change the cartridges. They are also available on Amazon Subscribe and Save at a competitive price, making it even more convenient to keep up with maintenance.

As a side note, I tried using chlorine tablets as a substitute for the Fluidmaster cartridges, as many others have done. However, I found this option to be less desirable for a few reasons. Firstly, the chlorine smell was unbearable, even with just one tablet. Using bromine tablets may be a better alternative for this issue. Secondly, the chlorine tablets continued to dissolve inside the cleaning system, even when the toilet was not used frequently. This led to toxic levels of fumes when I eventually flushed the toilet. In contrast, the Fluidmaster refills do not seem to have this problem. They remain intact in toilets that are not used often and dissolve at a reasonable rate in more frequently used toilets. This ensures that they remain effective for a longer period, and I only need to replace the cartridges every 2-3 months.

I installed the Saniflo system in my basement as part of a finished basement project back in 2005, and I must say, it has exceeded my expectations. Even though it took me until 2019 to write this review, I have been thoroughly impressed with its performance over the years.

I did my research and decided to go with Saniflo, and it has been a fantastic investment. I had a plumber connect the system to serve the toilet, shower, bathroom sink, and wet bar sink on the other side of the bathroom wall. The system has been working like a charm for 14 years, and I regularly use the shower since I exercise in the basement.

During the construction process, I had the idea to build the pump itself into the wall and extend the discharge pipe. I also added sound insulation around the unit to minimize any noise from the pump. Additionally, I created a frame around the pump using magnets so that I can easily take it apart for servicing, although I haven't needed to do so yet.

This system has been worth every penny, as it has allowed me to install a second bathroom and shower next to the washers and dryers without having to break the floor to make a hole. It was the perfect solution for our basement.

My husband didn't encounter any issues during the installation of the macerated toilet. We initially ordered it through a national home improvement store, but it arrived without parts. We cancelled that order and ordered through Amazon instead, and it arrived within a week, complete and exceptionally well packed. The company that sent it also reached out to us with a helpful email, assuring us that they were available for any assistance we may need. The installation itself was straightforward, and we were able to hook up a bathtub and sink without any problems.

I was also impressed with the packaging of this toilet. It was packed with great care and arrived in three packages, all in perfect condition. If you're worried about it arriving damaged, don't be – the packaging is top-notch.

In terms of installation, I found it to be relatively straightforward. I used shark bite connectors to splice into the water line, and the PVC connection for the drain was typical. The porcelain is of high quality, and the toilet works great. It has been a great addition to my "Man Cave," and I plan to add a vanity and enclose it in the future.

I have tried multiple replacement parts from various stores such as Home Depot, Menards, and Ace Hardware, but none of them worked for my toilet. The universal models were too bulky and either hit the supply tube or the other wall when installed in reverse. Additionally, no matter how I adjusted the chain, the flapper did not flip high enough. However, I finally found the perfect replacement with this product. It required no adjustments and worked flawlessly.

Previously, I had visited all the local stores in search of a toilet handle, but none of them had what I needed. We had to flush using the chain instead. The handles labeled as universal did not fit our side flush handle as they all had a preformed bend in them. Thankfully, this product was exactly what we were looking for and we couldn't find it anywhere else.

I was extremely satisfied with this purchase as none of the stores in town carried the side handle. It took me only five minutes to install, and it worked perfectly. This lever is the only one I could find that comes with a straight lifting arm, which is required for side-mounted flushing arm commodes. Other brands had various types of angled arms that did not work even after attempting to straighten them. Therefore, I highly recommend buying this product if you are in a similar situation. The only downside is that it does not come in white.

After numerous unsuccessful trips to the store, I decided to order this replacement handle. It only took me about three minutes to install, and it worked like a charm. I am so satisfied with this product that I will be ordering another one to keep as a spare.

I recently had a slow leak in my toilet, so I decided to purchase a repair kit to fix the issue. Unfortunately, the first kit I tried did not solve the problem, as the leak persisted. Determined to find a solution, I turned to YouTube for guidance and discovered that the issue was likely a leak at the overflow tube. After watching a helpful video tutorial, I was able to replace the tube in just 15 minutes. Since then, I've had no more leaks or running toilet problems.

As a retired individual on a fixed income, being able to handle my own repairs is crucial for saving money. This repair kit came with clear instructions, and I found numerous informative videos on YouTube that helped me with the installation and basic repairs using this equipment. With a little patience and careful study of the instructions, anyone can successfully complete this repair.

I used this repair kit for my 1.6 gpf Gerber 21-752 toilet, along with a Gerber 99-591 gasket, and it worked perfectly. If you have a Gerber toilet, I recommend looking up the 99-591 gasket to use with this kit, as it is designed for taller gaskets. I opted to reuse the plastic nuts from my old toilet instead of using the included metal ones, as I didn't want to risk cracking the porcelain. Additionally, I simply followed the pattern of the bolts I removed, rather than strictly adhering to the instructions.

One quick tip I discovered during the process was aligning the bottom of the old and new flush valves to determine where to cut the overflow tube. This method was faster for me than using a ruler, as I could easily measure multiple times and still end up with incorrect measurements.

I recently purchased the American Standard H2Option Siphonic Dual Flush Elongated Toilet and I must say, I am thoroughly impressed. First and foremost, the packaging was top-notch. Unlike my previous experience with toilet shipments, this one came with foam-filled packets that were easy to remove and dispose of. No messy white beads or excessive packaging. Everything arrived in excellent condition, thanks to the careful packaging.

The prep and setup process was relatively straightforward. I highly recommend lifting the old toilet and placing a large contractor garbage bag underneath to avoid any water or wax spills. Two people make this task much easier. Removing the old wax with a flat putty knife and cleaning the toilet flange with disposable paper shop towels ensures a clean and smooth installation. Overall, the demo and cleanup took me only 30 minutes.

Now, let's talk about the bowl. It is not only aesthetically pleasing but also functions exceptionally well. The two-level flushing system is a game-changer. After watching a video of this toilet flushing golf balls effortlessly, I knew it was the one for me. I have been using it consistently for the past seven months and have encountered zero issues. The comfort height is also a major plus, making it comfortable for people of all ages.

Contrary to some reviews I came across, I have had no problems with the buttons. They function perfectly, and I have not needed to make any adjustments. I primarily use the #1 button for #2s, and it flushes everything down without any issues. The #2 button is rarely used in my household. To enhance the overall experience, I paired this toilet with the Brondell LumaWarm seat warmer, and it has been fantastic.

In fact, I am so impressed with this toilet that I recently purchased three more for my new house. The combination of its sleek design, efficient flushing system, and overall performance makes it a fantastic choice. If you are in the market for a reliable and high-quality toilet, I highly recommend the American Standard H2Option Siphonic Dual Flush Elongated Toilet. You won't be disappointed.

I recently purchased this toilet after experiencing issues with my previous one. I was pleasantly surprised by how well this toilet performs compared to my previous one. I used to have to flush multiple times just to get the paper down with a pee, but with this toilet, it's a breeze. I initially thought that the problem was with my septic system, but it turns out I was mistaken.

I had to buy the linen color to match my other fixtures, which increased the price slightly, but I have no regrets as I am completely satisfied with my purchase. The installation process was easy, especially with the help of a friend. I do want to mention that there is a plastic wrench included to help tighten the bolts under the tank, which we initially overlooked. We wasted some time trying to tighten the bolts with a socket set, so make sure to use the included plastic wrench.

I considered purchasing the more expensive Toto single low flush toilet, but I had to give it up because the handle would have been too close to the sink. However, I am happy with my decision as this toilet has a .98 gallon flush, which means I never feel the need to save water by flushing every other time. This has also resulted in less cleaning being necessary.

The delivery process was a bit of a mess-up as the item is sent in two packages. If only one package arrives, I recommend waiting a day or two before reordering. However, I must commend Amazon's customer service chatline for being very helpful in resolving any issues.

My husband did extensive research on toilets before we made this purchase, and I must say, this toilet has lived up to its highly-rated reputation. I was particularly concerned about the water in the bowl, as our previous toilet always had a ring around the water line. However, this toilet is easy to clean and doesn't develop that nasty ring around the water stain. Additionally, I love the #1 and #2 flush options as they help save water.

As someone who frequently relies on Amazon for my home renovations, this toilet has been a game-changer. The water in my area is rusty, and my old toilet was not functioning well. However, this push-button dual flush toilet has been a wonder. I no longer have to flush twice, and water usage has been significantly reduced. I couldn't be happier with my purchase.

I recently installed the kit on three of my toilets, replacing old builder special systems that were about 8 years old. Overall, I found the kit to be quite good and it has greatly improved the functionality of my toilets.

The directions provided with the kit were mostly clear and easy to follow, but I did encounter some difficulties during the first installation. As someone with no plumbing experience but with a background in engineering, it took me about 3 hours and a fair amount of frustration to complete the first installation. However, the subsequent installations were much easier, taking about an hour for the second one and only 30 minutes for the final one.

One of the standout features of this kit is the adjustable flow level, which my husband particularly appreciates. It ensures that there is a strong flush that effectively clears the bowl without leaving anything behind. Additionally, the new system is noticeably quieter than the previous builder special systems, and there have been no leaks or issues with continuous running.

Having gone through the installation process, I have a few tips for those who are new to this kind of project. Firstly, after shutting off the water and disconnecting the water line, I recommend removing the tank completely (using a 13mm ratchet) and installing all the internal components in a comfortable workspace. I personally used my kitchen counter/sink and placed a towel down to protect the surface from scratches. You can then reattach the tank as the final step before turning the water back on.

Another important tip is to be aware of a big white plastic screw that is hidden under the red gasket of the provided flush valve. I initially missed this and struggled with what I thought was a pipe that was too short to attach properly. It wasn't until the second installation that I realized my mistake and had to go back and redo the first one. To save yourself the same trouble, remove the red gasket, take out the screw, and then put the red gasket back on.

For those whose toilet handle is located at the top of the tank, here are some simplified measurements to keep in mind: raise the fill valve height to about 0.5 inches from the top of the tank, mark the overflow valve at 3.5 inches from the top of the tank, and make minor adjustments afterwards using the tank water level screw.

Using a Dremel to cut the overflow valve can make the installation process easier and provide a cleaner cut. Additionally, I suggest looping or removing any excess length of chain from the flapper to the handle. If there is too much slack, it can get caught in the flush valve and cause the toilet to run. I personally looped mine back onto the handle clip.

Most of the parts needed for the installation came with the kit, with the exception of one. Therefore, I was able to discard all the old parts. However, I would recommend picking up an extra tank-to-bowl gasket for under the tank, as it was not included in the kit. It's more convenient to replace it during the installation, but you can also do it afterwards.

I recently had an issue with my toilet running loudly, so I decided to take matters into my own hands and fix it myself. After watching a few instructional videos, I came across the Mansfield MPP160 57 ball cock and decided to give it a try. I was pleasantly surprised when the package arrived earlier than expected.

Installing the Mansfield MPP160 57 was a breeze. As a 50-something-year-old woman, I was able to figure it out on my own without any trouble. The instructions provided were clear and easy to follow. Once installed, my toilet became quiet and started working perfectly.

One thing worth mentioning is that I needed to use a monkey wrench to remove the old ball cock. Unfortunately, I forgot to wear gloves and ended up getting the black rubber from the old washer on my hands. It was a minor inconvenience, but something to keep in mind for future reference.

During my research, I discovered that my toilet is a low flow one, using 1.6 gallons per flush. This meant that I couldn't find a dual flush unit that would work with my toilet. However, this wasn't an issue as I only needed to replace the fill valve, which the Mansfield MPP160 57 provided.

There were a couple of things I noticed during the installation process. Firstly, the fill tube was not connected to the fill valve in the box, so I had to do that myself. It would have been helpful if this was mentioned in the instructions. Secondly, I didn't need or use the tube connector clips for my toilet, as they were not compatible with the canister flush type. I ended up discarding them.

In terms of noise, the Mansfield MPP160 57 fill valve is louder than the Kohler one I had before. However, the loudness depends on the amount of water you want in the bowl. When set to low water, it is very quiet. Opening the bowl fill dial makes it noisier, but it's only for a few seconds. Personally, I don't flush at night to avoid disturbing anyone, so the noise wasn't a major concern for me.

Another observation I made was that the fill tube was too long for my toilet. I had to cut about 1.5" off both tubes to make it fit properly. Aside from that, the Mansfield MPP160 57 performed well and met my expectations.

The only downside I experienced was when I turned the water back on after installation. There was a flush of black muck from inside the flush valve into the tank. It didn't stain anything, but it took a few flushes and some manual swishing of the water to completely remove it. It would have been better if this was cleared out at the factory.

On a positive note, the knobs to adjust the water tank level and the water bowl level on the Mansfield MPP160 57 were clearly marked, eliminating the need for guesswork. Unlike my previous Kohler fill valve, no screwdriver was required for adjustments.

I recently purchased the Kohler toilet and seat to replace my previous toilet, which was causing discomfort and had a constantly loose seat. The installation process was relatively easy, although I did encounter a few minor issues. The toilet did not come with the necessary t-bolts to secure it to the floor, but I was able to use the hardware from my previous toilet. Additionally, I had to purchase a longer water supply line to accommodate the increased height of the new toilet. Once these issues were resolved, the installation went smoothly.

I am extremely satisfied with this combination of toilet and seat. The increased height of the toilet has eliminated the problem of leg numbness that I experienced with my previous toilet. The seat is also secure and does not move, providing me with peace of mind. The flush is quick, efficient, and surprisingly quiet. Overall, I am very happy with my decision to upgrade to this Kohler toilet and seat.

In terms of installation, I was initially concerned about the difficulty due to my petite stature. However, with the help of my husband, the process was actually quite easy. I particularly appreciate the three-bolt system that ensures a strong and stable connection between the tank and the base, eliminating any rocking.

Despite my initial concerns about the height of the toilet, I have found it to be perfect for my needs. Even as a 5-foot-tall woman, I find the height to be just right. The only minor issue I encountered was with the chain inside the tank, which caused improper flushing. However, this was easily fixed by adjusting the chain length. Overall, I am pleased with my decision to choose this Kohler toilet.

One of the main reasons I decided to replace my previous toilet was the loud noise it made when flushing. After 15 years of enduring this, I was ready for a change. After conducting thorough research, I settled on the Kohler K-3999-0 Highline Comfort 1.2-gallon toilet, and it was a fantastic decision. The toilet is incredibly quiet and efficiently flushes away all waste in just one flush. Additionally, it has a visually pleasing design.

Based on my experience, I highly recommend the Kohler K-3999-0 Highline Comfort toilet if you are looking for a quiet, efficient, and visually appealing option.

After careful consideration and following the instructions provided, I can confidently say that this product is worth the purchase. Despite some complex instructions, if you take the time to read through them before installation, you will be satisfied with the results. Not only does this product save you money by avoiding the need for a new dual flush toilet, but it also helps reduce waste by keeping ceramic out of landfills.

However, there are a few things to keep in mind when purchasing this device. Firstly, the manufacturer's support may not be reliable, as I experienced difficulty in reaching them for assistance. It is advisable to be prepared to resolve any issues yourself. Secondly, during installation, you may encounter parts that require firm pressure and make loud snapping sounds. Don't be alarmed, as this is normal. Just be cautious, but not overly gentle.

Furthermore, when installing the dual-flush converter, the blue float initially comes set to the highest point, which uses the smallest amount of water for a light flush. It is important to note that repeatedly light-flushing the toilet during calibration may lead to false positive results. To ensure consistent successful flushing, it is recommended to adjust the blue float to about five clicks from the lowest setting. This still uses significantly less water than a full flush.

To properly calibrate the device, follow these steps:

1. Install and calibrate the device according to the instructions.

2. Press firmly down on the blue float until it reaches its lowest point.

3. Use the toilet normally for a day or two.

4. Once you've confirmed consistent successful light flushes, pull the blue float up three clicks.

5. Repeat steps 2-4 until failed light flushes occur.

6. Press the blue float down one click.

7. Use the toilet normally for a day or two.

8. If failed light flushes occur, repeat steps 6 and 7 until they don't.

9. Rest assured knowing that your light flush is properly calibrated.

As an update, I have purchased two more of these devices for my upstairs bathrooms, indicating my satisfaction with their performance.

A further update in May 2014 reveals that the supplied zip-tie securing the flush meter to the fill pipe has broken in all three of my installations. While this may not be a major issue due to the rubber o-ring securing the gasket, it is advisable to replace the supplied zip-tie with a sturdier one purchased separately, especially for first-time installations.

In December 2014, one of my installations failed after approximately 26 months. However, it is worth noting that my other two installations are still functioning well, suggesting that this may not be a defect in the device itself.