I Tested And Reviewed 10 Best Gas Fireplace Inserts (2023)

I recently purchased the Duluth Forge log set and I must say, I am quite impressed with the quality and performance of this product. The flames on the logs can be adjusted, although it requires using the control knob on the logs themselves rather than the remote control. While the remote control does not control the height of the flame, it still serves its purpose well with an on/off function and a temperature control feature that provides convenience and peace of mind.

One thing worth mentioning is that if you are specifically looking for remote control of flame height, you may need to invest in a higher-priced option, ranging from $800 to $1000. However, considering the overall value for money, the Duluth Forge log set definitely stands out among its competitors. The heating capability of these logs is truly impressive and exceeded my expectations. They provide efficient heat, making my space cozy and comfortable during the colder months.

I also want to highlight the excellent packaging of the Duluth Forge log set. The logs are securely packaged in custom foam that surrounds each piece, ensuring that they arrive intact and undamaged. This attention to detail reflects the commitment of Duluth Forge to delivering a fantastic product.

In comparison to a higher-priced Peterson unit I purchased alongside the Duluth Forge, I must say that the Duluth Forge log set gives the Peterson unit a run for its money. While it may not come with all the extras like lava rock and embers, the Duluth Forge log set performs just as well and has a pleasant aesthetic appeal considering its price point. Additionally, the Duluth Forge log set has some features that the Peterson unit lacks, such as thermostatic control and a thermometer on the remote.

I had a positive experience with the customer support provided by Factory Buys Direct. When I encountered a technical issue, they promptly answered my call and resolved the problem. Their exceptional tech support is noteworthy and sets them apart from other companies.

(Note: It is important to research the difference between vented and non-vented logs, as they serve different purposes and functionalities. Consider your preferences for heat and aesthetics when making your decision. Happy logging!)

The bag of glowing embers does its job effectively and adds a visually pleasing element to the fireplace. However, it should be noted that the bag contains more than enough embers for just one fireplace, which may lead to excess leftover. On the positive side, this means that the product can be easily replaced over the years.

The embers create a beautiful glow under gas logs and only a small amount is needed, ensuring that the bag will last for an extended period of time. This makes it a good value for the price.

While the quantity of 4 ounces may not seem like a lot, it is actually more than enough for most users. The reviewer found that they only needed a few pinches for their gas logs and still had a significant amount of embers left in the bag. The longevity of the embers is also impressive, as they remained unchanged even after a month of use. This may create a dilemma of what to do with the excess embers.

In the case of a reviewer who had not utilized their fireplace for a long time, the purchase of the glowing embers was a game-changer. The embers added a realistic touch to their ventless gas logs and provided warmth to the room. The reviewer also found that the bag contained a substantial amount of embers, enough to share with their sister. Overall, the purchase was highly satisfactory.

I recently replaced the gas log substrate in my fireplace with this product, and I must say, the performance and visual appeal of the glowing embers are incredibly realistic. Just one bag of this product was enough to achieve the desired effect.

We are absolutely thrilled with this product! It was so simple to use – all we had to do was scatter it around in our gas fireplace, and it instantly enhanced the flame, making it look like actual embers. The result is truly beautiful.

The product lives up to its advertised claims. I have rearranged the ceramic logs and the glowing embers a couple of times, and it seems to work best when the product is spread out a bit, giving a more diffuse appearance of embers. I have been using this product for about a month now, and so far, it has performed flawlessly.

Not only does it look great, but there is also a generous amount of product in each bag. I was pleasantly surprised by how much was included.

I received the glowing embers exactly as stated, and they were packaged really well. Although I have not had a chance to use them yet due to the weather, I am looking forward to using them in the winter. I was particularly pleased with how quickly they arrived, as I had just installed new gas logs.

I am extremely satisfied with this product. It has added a cozy and inviting ambiance to our gas fireplace with its beautiful ember glow. I only used a little less than half a bag for our 15" fire logs in a 30" fireplace. While it didn't contain much vermiculite, I already had some in the fireplace, so it wasn't a problem. Overall, I am very pleased with the results.

What's even better is that this product is the same material that came with my fireplace insert when I first installed it. The only difference is that I got a lot more of it for a much lower price compared to the local fireplace vendor. It works just as well as the original material and will last for many years to come. I want to emphasize that I have no affiliation with the vendor or manufacturer of this product, but I highly recommend it.

One thing I must mention is that I had a hard time finding the country of origin in the product description. Even in the photos of the package, it wasn't clearly stated. After some research, I found out that it is made in China. If the country of origin is important to you, there you have it. However, despite this, the product performs exceptionally well and is more affordable compared to similar products made in the USA.

The product arrived on time and was very easy to use. It adds a great visual appeal when burning and has enhanced the overall look of our fireplace. My wife accidentally threw out the existing mineral wool, mistaking it for dirty lint. Thankfully, this product was a breeze to install and looks fantastic when in use. Not only did it replace the original material, but there was also some left over. Additionally, the price was much more reasonable compared to local gas fireplace shops.

I am extremely satisfied with these fire logs. We have a medium-sized fireplace and they fit perfectly. We have been using them for three weeks now and there have been no unpleasant smells. The logs have not changed color and they emit a beautiful glow when they are hot. I do wish I had a dual burner to fully experience the effects of these logs, so I will be purchasing one soon.

The birch logs, rock wool, and lava stone that I bought along with the fire logs have exceeded my expectations. The rock wool is easy to fluff up and place around the burner to achieve a good fuel-air mixture. The lava stone provides excellent insulation. Unlike my previous logs, these ones have not deteriorated. In fact, they radiate even more heat now.

What's great about these fire logs is that they are much more affordable compared to rigid sets that end up looking the same. While they may not fool someone who closely inspects them, from a normal distance of over six feet with the fire going, it's difficult to tell the difference. They are surprisingly light, which indicates they may be fragile, so handle them with care and enjoy the warmth they provide.

I have been using these logs for a few months now and I am finally writing a review. I added six pieces to my existing two large anchor logs and they create a great visual when they burn. They burn cleanly and leave no odor or residue in the air. There is a small amount of black burn residue that occasionally develops on some parts of the logs, but I easily resolve this by spraying them with a gas log smooth remover before turning on my fireplace. Overall, I am extremely pleased with these logs and they look fantastic when they burn.

When we moved into our new house, both of the gas fireplaces were missing logs. I was shocked at the prices of traditional logs, which were well over $600. Thankfully, I found these logs on Amazon and they were the perfect solution for both of our fireplaces. They have a beautiful appearance and function perfectly. It is expected that they may get some black smudging, but that does not detract from their overall performance. I am very happy with this purchase and highly recommend these logs.

I am thrilled with these ceramic logs! Not only are they priced very competitively, but they also deliver on quality and aesthetics. I highly recommend them.

I purchased these logs specifically for my outdoor firepit, and they have exceeded my expectations. Despite being lightweight, they convincingly resemble real burning wood, adding an authentic touch to my natural gas firepit. I appreciate that they eliminate the mess associated with using real wood.

One of the standout features of these logs is the afterglow they emit when turned off. It creates a pleasant effect, mimicking the glow of real wood for several minutes. I have only used them outdoors, so I cannot comment on any potential smell indoors.

I was impressed by the quantity of logs included in the set. The number shown in my photos is only half of the set, providing enough to achieve a realistic look. Additionally, having extra logs for future use is a bonus.

The product arrived on time, and all the pieces were intact. They are not overly heavy but have a decent weight to them, adding to their authenticity.

I am extremely impressed with this product. It functions flawlessly and fulfills its purpose effectively. My only minor issue is the color of the material when the fire is not lit. It appears to be tan/white and lacks a natural appearance. However, this concern is quickly resolved as the color becomes more realistic once the fire begins. Overall, I find this product to be superior to the small amount of material that came with the log set.

Initially, I purchased this product to replace the inadequate "embers" in my gas fireplace. I was pleasantly surprised by its performance. I only needed a fraction of what was provided in the bag, but I am excited to experiment with it in our gas fire pit in the upcoming spring season.

To my amazement, these embers actually work. They create the illusion of real embers beneath the artificial logs in my gas fireplace. I would like to emphasize that you do not need to purchase two bags as only a minimal amount is necessary to achieve a satisfying ember effect. Using more than the recommended amount can negatively impact the appearance of the flames. I speak from experience on this matter.

The application process of this product is incredibly simple, and it is easy to work with. Once installed, it may take a short while before the embers create a realistic "ember" look. However, I can assure you that the brief wait is worth it.

The ceramic logs provided a realistic and updated appearance to my gas fireplace. The quality of the logs was impressive, and their size was suitable for my relatively small fireplace. I was able to use only a few logs, saving the rest for future use.

Previously, my fireplace had old gas logs that were deteriorating. The new light wood logs not only look better but also weigh less, enhancing the overall aesthetic of the fireplace.

I initially ordered four different sets of logs from Amazon, anticipating that I would need to return most of them. However, this particular set stood out as the most authentic-looking from all angles and had superior quality compared to the others. My only disappointment was the lack of larger size options.

These logs are stunning and instantly transformed the look of our fireplace. I am extremely satisfied with their appearance and highly recommend them. Additionally, they ignite easily and provide both warmth and a cozy ambiance.

The Pro-com fireplace is a great addition to any home. The design is sleek and modern, adding a touch of elegance to any room. The installation process was smooth, especially with the anticipation of having a gas line installed.

One minor issue we encountered was with the screen, but thankfully, Shane from Pro-com promptly resolved the problem. His customer service was exceptional, and he went above and beyond to ensure our satisfaction. It's always reassuring to know that a company stands behind its product and is willing to address any concerns.

The functionality of the fireplace is impressive. It works flawlessly, providing both warmth and ambiance. However, we do advise inspecting the product upon delivery, as our first unit arrived damaged. Thankfully, Amazon swiftly replaced it without any hassle. We appreciate their efficient and helpful assistance throughout the process.

I recently purchased these smaller gas fireplace logs to fill in the empty spaces in my existing log set. I was pleased to find that they fit nicely and were small enough to easily move around without taking up too much room. The logs have a very natural appearance and match my other logs perfectly. Overall, I am very happy with this purchase.

I have a 50" electric wall fireplace that came without any logs, only small clear pebbles. I decided to order these logs in the hopes that they would fit in the narrow space between the front and back glass, which is about 1.5" wide. However, I did have to trim the logs down by about 0.5" to make them fit. I used a tile saw initially, but later discovered that soaking the logs in water for a few minutes made them easy to cut with a bread knife. I painted the trimmed edges with black paint and was able to install them without any issues. The logs are truly beautiful and have greatly enhanced the overall aesthetics of my fireplace.

If you're looking to add some volume to your existing log set, these logs are a great option. They will effectively beef up the appearance of your current set. However, if you plan on using these logs as your only set, you may need to purchase multiple sets or consider a different product.

I bought these logs as a perfect addition to my faux fireplace, and they have exceeded my expectations. They are incredibly realistic and lightweight, making them easy to handle. I specifically bought them to fill in the open spaces in my fake log set, and I couldn't be more pleased with the outcome.

These logs are ideal for my propane fire bowl. While they are small, their size is clearly stated in the product description, and I purchased them with the intention of having smaller logs. I am even considering buying another set to further enhance the realism of the fire. Overall, I am highly satisfied with this product.