I Tested And Reviewed 10 Best Screen Doors For Front Door (2023)

I recently purchased this magnetic screen door to replace my old one that was damaged by my two boxers. I am extremely impressed with the quality and durability of this product. The materials used are strong and the weights at the bottom prevent the door from opening with the wind. The mesh is also much stronger and the velcro around the entire screen ensures a secure fit to the door frame. The best feature is the magnets, which only open when pushed.

Installation was a breeze and the magnets align back perfectly. This screen door effectively keeps out unwanted intruders while allowing fresh air to flow through. I highly recommend this product.

This is actually the third magnetic screen door I have purchased, and compared to the previous two, this one is made of much heavier duty material. It feels like a coated mesh that is very substantial. The added weights at the bottom are a great addition as they prevent the door from being blown open by a breeze. The magnets are also very strong and seem to be sewn into place. My pets have no trouble using the door, and it effectively keeps flies and other bugs out. The installation process is super easy. Overall, this is a great buy!

I was considering installing a storm door but didn't want to spend the money. This magnetic screen door turned out to be the perfect solution for me. It allows fresh air in while keeping flying bugs out. The magnetic closure is strong and easily falls back into place when going in and out. Even my indoor cat doesn't attempt to go outside when the door is closed. The adhesive used to install the screen is also very strong, so make sure to position it correctly the first time.

During the warmer months, I like to keep my backdoor open for my dog to freely roam inside and outside. However, this often leads to flies and other insects entering the house. I decided to purchase this magnetic screen door to solve this problem. I appreciate that it comes in white to match my trim and outside door, unlike other screens that are only available in black. The installation process was quick and easy, taking me less than 30 minutes. The only slightly challenging part was finding the middle of the door and aligning it with the middle of the screen.

I opted to use the push pins for hanging instead of the adhesive backing, and it worked perfectly for me. I was initially concerned that my dog would have trouble using the door or that it wouldn't fully close behind her, but both of these concerns have been proven wrong. She simply uses her nose to push against the screen, allowing it to open and close effortlessly. Occasionally, if she runs out quickly, the screen may get stuck to the metal door, but this is a rare occurrence. Overall, this screen door has been a success in keeping bugs out and allowing fresh air in.

I recently purchased this screen protector and I must say, I am extremely satisfied with its performance. The heavy-duty feel of the protector is evident and it has proven effective in keeping bugs out. While there is a small bottom opening that sometimes gets caught when walking inside, it is not a major issue for me. My puppy can freely go in and out without us worrying about flies entering our home.

One thing I did have to do was use the tacks that came with the protector as the tape started to come off at the corners. This extra reinforcement made the protector even more sturdy. I did notice that it does not open all the way, possibly due to the design, but the strong magnetic closure compensates for this.

In terms of installation, it was relatively easy with the help of my partner. I would recommend having two people for the installation process, with one person holding the protector while the other helps stick it in place. However, I did have an issue with the double-sided tape removing some of the paint from my door, so be cautious of that.

This particular protector has a side opening, which is perfect for me as I have a couch a few inches over the door opening inside. The magnetic closure is surprisingly secure, yet still easy for my 16 lb yorkie and 4-year-old to navigate through. So far, it has been functioning perfectly and I am extremely satisfied with this purchase.

I have had previous experiences with magnetic screens over the past 6 years, and I must say that this brand stands out as the nicest one. The Velcro is sturdy and the adhesive is incredibly sticky. I have tried both white and black screens, and I prefer the black as it allows more light in compared to the white screen. The black screen appears darker in the pictures, but in person, it is nearly see-through when the sun shines in.

Additionally, the side opening of this protector is more convenient for me, especially when I have my hands full of grocery bags and need to get the key in the door handle. Overall, I am very pleased with the quality, price, and functionality of this screen protector and highly recommend it to others. Just be sure to measure your door opening correctly to ensure the right fit. Finally, I am delighted that I can now keep my balcony door open without worrying about flies or bugs entering my home.

I am extremely pleased with this magnetic screen door. It came with adhesion strips, which I found to be convenient. However, I was disappointed to discover that the net and the strips were not adjustable to fit different sizes of door frames, especially since I live in an apartment. Despite this minor setback, I still love the item.

The installation process was not as easy as I had hoped due to unclear instructions. Nevertheless, I purchased two of these magnetic screens; one for my front door and one for my back door. I found them to be super easy to install and the quality exceeded my expectations. Compared to the initial plan of building a wooden structure with a roll of screen, these magnetic screens provided a more simplistic solution.

Originally, I intended to construct a screened-in structure using wood 2x4s and screen material. However, upon receiving the magnetic screen, I was impressed by its weight and excellent quality. This prompted me to abandon the wood construction, saving me nearly $400 in materials and countless hours of labor. Instead, I opted to enclose the patio area under my home by ordering an additional 14 pieces of the magnetic screen.

Living on Long Island, I often face challenges such as flooding, mosquitoes, and high winds during the summer. The sheer white curtains I previously used proved to be ineffective against mosquitoes and were easily torn by my dogs. In contrast, these magnetic screens are durable and come with weighted bottoms. They are also removable, making it easy to store them during the winter or in preparation for high winds or hurricanes.

The screens are secured to the structure using Velcro and took less than two hours to install completely. I appreciate the accurate sizing, especially since most other brands only offer a standard doorway height, which would have been too short for my patio. I was delighted to find the 98-inch height option. However, I do wish that they were available in wider widths at that height. Nonetheless, I discovered that Velcroing them securely together creates a stable curtain, and the weighted bottoms keep them in place.

We recently installed this screen for our apartment balcony door and we couldn't be happier with the results. Not only does it look great, but the quality is top-notch as well. The side opening feature is absolutely brilliant, allowing us to easily open the double locks and door with just one hand. Unlike other versions with a middle seam, this screen doesn't require us to move half of it out of the way to open the door.

One of the best things about this screen is that it effectively keeps out bugs while still allowing us to enjoy the view and a refreshing breeze. The magnets are strong enough to keep the screen securely closed, but not too strong for our cat to navigate through. He figured it out quickly and the magnets snap right back into place after he passes through.

The installation process was relatively easy. We simply needed some floor space to spread the screen out flat and set the double-sided tape strips to the outer edges. We made sure to clean the door frame thoroughly before sticking it on, and it has been holding up well for over a month now. For added security, we also secured the two bottom corners with tacks.

One thing worth mentioning is that the screen hangs mostly flat, giving it a nice appearance. It doesn't look limp or wavy like some other screens we've seen. Overall, we are extremely satisfied with this product and would highly recommend it to anyone in need of a reliable and aesthetically pleasing screen for their balcony or patio door.

In addition to our balcony door, we also have a green cheek conure in our bedroom. We keep him fully flighted, so we were concerned about the possibility of him flying out when someone is cooking or walking outside. Thankfully, the frame outside our door has a spot where the structure of the house overlaps it, but it was easy to work around. We had no problem putting up the screen, and it only took us about 5 minutes. We are particularly impressed with the way the door closes on its own, providing peace of mind and allowing our birdie to fly around without the worry of him escaping unattended.

Lastly, we are extremely pleased with this screen as an alternative to replacing sliding screen doors in our family room leading to the outdoor deck. Not only are they cost-effective, but they also perform exceptionally well and look great. Initially, we bought the white screens to match the exterior of our doors, but we quickly realized that they were difficult to see through, especially when the sun is shining on them. Taking the advice of another reviewer, we easily returned them and opted for the grey screens instead, which have proven to be a better choice. The side opening feature provides a clear view from the door, and the magnetic strip works beautifully.

For added security and to ensure that the screen stays down, we purchased a magnetic weight to attach to the bottom. This has worked perfectly, as we are not fans of critters and bugs finding their way into our house. Our grand dog even tried to slip through, but thanks to this screen, he was unable to do so.

I recently moved to SE Arizona and while I love living here, I have been dealing with a constant bug problem since day one. Moths and flies have been particularly troublesome, and no matter what I tried, they always found their way into my home.

That's when I came across these amazing screens. I was initially attracted to the affordable price and decided to give them a try. The extra length of the screen was a bit of a challenge, but I easily fixed it by rolling the top and adding a few stitches to keep it neat. I then installed the velcro, along with a trim board for added support. The fit was perfect, and there was no way any bugs could crawl in.

What impressed me the most were the magnets in the screen liner. They were unlike anything I had seen before and held the screen together really well. The screen itself is made of sturdy mesh and the stitching is of high quality. I tested it out on a hot day with lots of bees around, and not a single insect made its way inside my home.

It has been four months since I installed these screens, and despite the hot winds and monsoons we've experienced, they are still as good as new. Even my big dog running through them hasn't caused any damage. We occasionally get a fly, but it's nothing compared to what we used to deal with.

I have already recommended these screens to all my family members, and my sister, who lives in the country, has also become a fan. Her screens never last more than a few months due to her large dog, but these screens have proven to be durable even in that situation.

Maintenance is a breeze as well. Once a week, I simply wipe the white strips in the middle with a cloth and warm soapy water, and they look as good as new. I absolutely love these screens and will definitely be buying them as gifts for others.

The screen that I purchased is of exceptional quality and durability. I found it very easy to set up, as it came with Velcro that I cut to fit the top and sides of the door frame. I made sure to attach the top portion securely above the door so that it wouldn't come loose at the bottom. The Velcro and reinforced screen are both incredibly strong and well-made. Additionally, the magnets on the screen are very powerful.

One of the things that I particularly appreciate about this screen is its design and installation process. The screen fabric is made from a strong material that can withstand accidental pokes or tears. It also has a nice gray or silver color that blends well with the door and is hardly noticeable. Unlike other magnetic screen designs, this model doesn't have any annoying black stripes and offers a clear and unobtrusive view.

Another advantage of this screen is that it comes in various sizes, making it easier to find the perfect fit for your door. The installation process is straightforward, and the gum adhesive on the back of the Velcro sticks securely to the door frame and header. However, I would recommend using the provided tacks along the top strip, as the strip itself, although wider than the side strips, may eventually start to pull away.

One minor issue I encountered was that the vendor mistakenly described the top Velcro strip as being 4 inches wide, when in reality, it is 1.5 inches wide. Nevertheless, this width is more than adequate for installation purposes, and a wider strip might not fit some door frames. The vertical side Velcro strips, on the other hand, are 3/4 inches wide.

UPDATED OBJECTIVE REVIEW:

After using the Magic Mesh for a while, I have realized that the initial issues I had were mostly my own fault. The mesh was too small for my door, causing it to not always close properly and eventually developing a tear. This tear became a safety concern as my dogs' heads would sometimes get stuck in it. However, I have since ordered a larger size and found that it fits perfectly.

Installing the Magic Mesh was a breeze, especially since the velcro tape from the previous mesh was still intact on my door frame. The sticky adhesive was still strong, only requiring a few adjustments and additional tape to secure the new mesh. The new mesh now fits flawlessly and closes almost all the way, with only a minor gap at the bottom that can easily be nudged closed.

Considering that the right size makes a significant difference in the overall experience, I am now giving the Magic Mesh a five-star rating. While it may not be perfect, it does the job effectively and surpasses the "good enough" criteria.

Now, let's delve into the pros and cons of the Magic Mesh objectively:

PROS:

1. The Magic Mesh lives up to its claims and effectively keeps insects out while allowing easy access for pets.

2. The material used is durable, withstanding regular use by my dogs without showing signs of wear and tear.

3. The adhesive on the velcro strips is strong, and there is an ample amount of extra velcro for future replacement if needed.

4. Dogs quickly adapt to using the Magic Mesh once they understand how it works.

CONS:

1. The mesh is narrow and may not fit all door frames perfectly, requiring adjustments and precise positioning.

2. Achieving a tight fit while maintaining proper magnetic closure may take some trial and error.

3. There might be small gaps around the sides, which can be sealed with additional measures like packing tape to prevent smaller insects from entering.

I have been using this screen door for the past 7 months, and I am still thrilled with its performance. Despite being exposed to the sun, it has only faded slightly and remains in great condition. To ensure a more secure attachment to my house, I used a staple gun, which has worked well. There was a minor issue with one of the magnets falling out, but it was easily fixed by sewing it back in (non-sewers could use super glue as an alternative).

This screen door has endured a lot of abuse, from extreme temperatures to the constant activity of three German Shepherds running through it multiple times a day. Despite this, it continues to function perfectly, providing an effective barrier against bugs. I highly recommend this screen door as a practical alternative to a sliding screen door. It has exceeded my expectations in terms of quality and ease of use.

Although I plan to replace it next spring, I am extremely pleased with its durability and performance. It is definitely worth the investment. I would love to always have a screen door like this.

With three German Shepherds using it regularly, the screen door has proven to be durable and reliable. It closes nicely behind them and remains intact even when I walk through carrying things. In fact, I am considering replacing my sliding screen door with this product for added convenience.

I recently purchased both the Sentry and Magzo screens as I was unable to decide between the two based on the reviews. While I haven't had them long enough to comment on their durability, I do have some suggestions and comparisons regarding the purchase and installation process.

In terms of product comparison, I initially bought what was advertised as the 36" x 80" size for both brands. However, I noticed that the actual dimensions were different. The Sentry screen measured 79" x 37" while the Magzo screen was indeed 36" x 80" as advertised. Other than this, the screen material and magnets along the closure seemed identical. The Sentry screen did come with weights on the bottom edge, which may make it more resistant to wind. Additionally, the packaging of the Sentry screen was more elaborate and thoughtful compared to the Magzo screen.

Moving on to installation, the two brands provided different instructions. Sentry advised attaching the velcro tape to the door frame and then securing the screen to it, while Magzo recommended sticking the tape on the screen itself and peeling off the backing as you install it. I opted for the Magzo method as it seemed easier for one person to handle. In retrospect, I would recommend using the Magzo approach for another reason, especially if you're installing a screen without any excess material in width. With the Magzo method, you can easily gauge the tension of the screen as you stick the tape on. In my case, I had to adjust the position of the tape to ensure a flat screen. If I had installed the tape first, I would have positioned it differently, resulting in excess material in the width.

When considering the purchase, I suggest opting for screens with strong magnets on the closure and velcro all the way around, like these two brands. Previously, I bought screens from a local merchant that were easy to install as they hung from a spring tension rod and had only a few velcro tabs and a large magnet for closure. However, the magnet was too strong, making it difficult to open the screen, and the velcro tabs didn't hold up well. Therefore, I highly recommend screens with ample magnets and velcro for a secure closure.

Some screens claim to be adjustable for different door sizes, but I'm unsure how that would work practically. Perhaps you could cut the velcro strip off the sides or top and then glue it back onto the screen, but this would significantly increase installation effort. Instead, I suggest purchasing a screen that fits your door dimensions without the need for alterations. With various screen sizes available, finding one that fits perfectly is ideal.

When deciding on the screen size for your door, keep two things in mind. Firstly, consider where you plan to stick the velcro, and secondly, consider the size of the screen itself. There is a 1" border around the top and sides of the screen. The Sentry screen will cover a 35" door opening, while the Magzo screen will cover a 34" opening, assuming the screens are flat. If your door height is 80", neither screen will touch the bottom of the door due to the velcro strip across the top. In my case, I planned to install the screens with the velcro strips facing each other and the screen at right angles to the strips. However, this doesn't allow for width adjustment unless you cut the screen. Ultimately, I attached the velcro to the outside of the frame, allowing me to adjust the width and ensure a flat screen. Unless you are willing to cut the screen or it fits perfectly by attaching the velcro to the inside of the frame, I recommend planning to install it on the outside, aligning the screen and velcro in the same plane.

Finally, I want to mention that the included pins for installation only work on wooden frames. Since my frame was metal, I purchased 3/4" pan head black sheet metal screws to secure the top and sides. I have only used them on one of the doors for now, as I want to see how well the velcro holds up on the other one. If you choose to do this, be cautious as the screen can get wrapped up in the drill bit, and make sure to drill a hole slightly larger than the screw size, as metal is less forgiving than wood. Although I didn't use washers, I recommend using them as the holes in the screen borders may end up larger than the screw heads.

I recently purchased this magnetic screen door and I am extremely satisfied with my purchase. Firstly, the price was great and it was very easy to install. I was pleased to find that it effectively kept flies out of my house while allowing me to leave my door open.

Contrary to some negative reviews, I found the installation process to be simple and straightforward. By following the instructions provided, I had no issues with the adhesive or the Velcro sticking properly. It is important to note that cleaning the door frame as instructed ensures that the adhesive sticks effectively. Additionally, I did not require the use of the pins, further highlighting the convenience of this product.

The magnets on this screen door are perfectly adequate and do a great job of closing the screen securely. However, it is crucial to install the screen correctly to ensure that the magnets close properly. The instructions clearly state that the screen should be slightly loose to allow the magnets to close, and following this advice yielded excellent results. I even found a video that demonstrated the magnets working perfectly after installation.

Having previously purchased a different brand from Walmart, I can confidently say that this magnetic screen door is far superior. The screen material is much more durable and the overall construction is sturdier. Unlike my previous purchase, the magnets on this screen door are strong enough to force the screen to close back together. This feature was especially important to me as I have large dogs and was concerned about them pushing through a flimsy screen. This product has exceeded my expectations in terms of quality and functionality.

I also appreciate that this magnetic screen door came with Velcro strips for easy installation. However, it is worth noting that solely relying on the Velcro will not keep the screen securely in place. Tacking it down with nails ensures that it stays up and functions properly. With the combination of Velcro and nails, this screen door has proven to be highly effective and reliable.